How to Choose 5 axis CNC Machining or 7 Axis CNC Machining

How to Choose 5 axis CNC Machining or 7 Axis CNC Machining?

In deciding whether to choose 5-axis or 7-axis CNC machining, the key lies in understanding the complexity and precision required for your parts. 5-axis machines provide excellent versatility for complex geometries and multi-sided parts without the need for multiple setups. On the other hand, 7-axis machines offer greater flexibility and control, allowing for more intricate designs and the production of extremely complex parts. Essentially, your choice depends on the complexity of the part you are machining and the production efficiencies you aim to achieve.

Continuing with the topic, it’s crucial to consider how each option impacts your production. Stay tuned as we delve deeper into what 5-axis and 7-axis CNC machining involve, and explore their differences and benefits.

What is 5-Axis CNC Machining?

5-axis CNC machining refers to the ability of a CNC machine to move a part or a cutting tool along five different axes simultaneously. This advanced technology enables the machining of complex parts that are difficult to do in traditional 3-axis systems. By operating on the X, Y, and Z linear axes and rotating on the A and B axes, this method allows the workpiece to be approached from any direction in a single setup.

 

What is 7-Axis CNC Machining?

7-axis CNC machining extends the capabilities of 5-axis machines by adding two additional axes, usually through a rotating table or a secondary moving arm. This sophisticated system allows the machine to manipulate the cutting tool or the workpiece along seven different axes simultaneously. The 7-axis CNC machine can perform turning operations like a lathe while also functioning as a milling machine, which provides exceptional versatility in a single setup.

 

 

Key Differences Between 5-Axis and 7-Axis CNC Machining

 

Feature 5-Axis CNC Machining 7-Axis CNC Machining
Axis of Movement X, Y, Z linear axes and two rotational axes (A, B) X, Y, Z linear axes, two rotational axes (A, B), plus two additional axes
Complexity High – Suitable for complex parts Very High – Suitable for very complex and intricate parts
Flexibility Very flexible, but less than 7-axis Extremely flexible, allows combining operations
Industries Aerospace, Automotive, Medical Aerospace, Robotics, Advanced Medical Devices
Operations Primarily milling Milling and turning in one setup
Setup Reduction Significant reduction in setups Further reduction in setups compared to 5-axis
Tool Access Improved access to part geometry Superior tool access and part manipulation

Benefits of 5-Axis CNC Machining

Enhanced Geometric Complexity: 5-axis CNC machines can handle complex geometries that are not possible with 3-axis machines. This allows for the production of more intricate designs without the need for multiple machine setups.

Improved Surface Finish: The ability to approach the workpiece from multiple angles reduces the need for manual finishing processes. This leads to a better surface finish directly off the machine, which is crucial for high-quality parts in industries like aerospace and automotive.

Reduced Setup Time: Because the machine can perform complex machining operations from multiple angles, it reduces the number of setups required. This not only speeds up the manufacturing process but also reduces the potential for errors associated with repositioning the part.

Increased Tool Life: The advanced control over the tool’s angle and position allows for optimal cutting conditions, which can extend tool life. This reduces the cost of tooling and downtime needed for replacements.

Faster Material Removal: 5-axis machines can maintain an optimal cutting position at all times, which allows for the use of the entire length of the tool. This results in faster material removal rates and shorter production times.

Greater Part Accuracy: By minimizing the number of setups, there is less chance of misalignment between operations. This increases the overall accuracy of the part, which is vital in industries requiring high precision.

Ability to Machine Challenging Materials: The precision and versatility of 5-axis machining make it suitable for working with challenging materials, including titanium and high-temperature alloys, often used in demanding sectors like medical and military applications.

Benefits of 7-Axis CNC Machining

Complex Part Geometry: With two additional axes, 7-axis CNC machines can produce extremely complex geometries that are often required in advanced engineering fields. This allows for the creation of parts with more intricate designs and features that cannot be machined on 5-axis machines.

Single Setup for Multiple Processes: One of the standout features of 7-axis machining is the ability to combine operations, such as milling and turning, in a single setup. This integration reduces handling and setup time dramatically, which can greatly increase production efficiency and reduce the likelihood of errors.

Improved Tool Accessibility: The additional axes provide superior tool access to various parts of the workpiece. This is especially beneficial for parts with hard-to-reach areas, ensuring more precise machining without the need for special tooling or setups.

Enhanced Surface Quality: 7-axis machines can maintain optimal tool orientation with respect to the workpiece surface, which improves the surface finish and reduces the need for post-machining finishing processes.

Faster Production Speeds: Because of the ability to perform multiple types of machining in one setup, 7-axis CNC machining can complete parts faster than machines with fewer axes. This is critical for reducing cycle times in high-volume production environments.

Increased Precision and Accuracy: The additional axes allow for better control over the machining process, which enhances the precision and accuracy of the finished parts. This is crucial in industries where even minor deviations can result in significant consequences, such as aerospace and medical devices.

Versatility in Machining: The flexibility in movement and capability to handle complex machining processes make 7-axis machines highly versatile. They can be adapted to a wide range of materials and part designs, which maximizes their utility in a production setting.

Cost Considerations: 5-Axis vs. 7-Axis CNC Machining

Initial Investment 

The purchase price of 7-axis CNC machines is typically higher than that of 5-axis machines due to their advanced capabilities and additional axes. This higher initial cost can be a significant factor, especially for smaller operations or those with limited budgets.

 

Tooling Costs

Both types of machines require specialized tooling, but the complexity and precision of 7-axis machines may necessitate more expensive tooling options. Additionally, the potential for using a wider variety of tools to achieve complex geometries can increase the overall tooling costs.

 

Maintenance and Repair 

With more moving parts and complex systems, 7-axis machines can be more costly to maintain and repair. The advanced technology and specialized skills required for servicing these machines also contribute to higher maintenance costs.

 

Training and Labor 

Operators for 7-axis machines typically need higher levels of training due to the complexity of the technology. This training can be more extensive and costly. Furthermore, the labor costs associated with highly skilled operators can be higher than those for less complex machines.

 

Production Efficiency 

While 7-axis machines have a higher upfront cost, they can offer greater production efficiency. This can lead to reduced cycle times and lower costs per part, especially in high-volume production environments where the machine’s advanced capabilities can be fully utilized.

 

Material Waste 

Both 5-axis and 7-axis machines provide high levels of precision that can reduce material waste compared to less advanced machines. However, the enhanced precision and flexibility of 7-axis machines can further minimize waste, particularly with expensive materials.

How to Assess Your CNC Machining Needs?

Understand Part Complexity 

Begin by evaluating the complexity of the parts you intend to produce. Consider the geometries, tolerances, and materials required. Machines like 5-axis and 7-axis CNCs are excellent for complex, multi-faceted parts that require high precision.

 

Analyze Production Volume

Determine your expected production volumes. For high-volume production, machines that can operate continuously and quickly, like 7-axis CNCs, may be more beneficial due to their efficiency and ability to handle complex operations in one setup.

 

Consider Material Requirements 

Different CNC machines are suited to different materials. Assess the types of materials you will be working with, whether metal, composites, or plastics, and ensure the CNC machine you consider can handle these effectively.

 

Evaluate Existing Capabilities 

Assess your current machining capabilities and identify gaps. If your existing equipment cannot meet the complexity or precision required for new projects, it may be time to consider an upgrade to more advanced machinery.

Conclusion

If you’re looking to elevate your production capabilities with advanced CNC machining, don’t hesitate to reach out. Our experts are ready to assist you in choosing the perfect solution that aligns with your specific manufacturing needs. Contact us today to explore our cutting-edge CNC options and get a competitive edge!

 

FAQ

What is the main difference between 5-axis and 7-axis CNC machines?
The main difference is that 7-axis CNC machines have two additional axes which allow for more complex and precise machining capabilities, including the integration of turning and milling in one setup.

Are 7-axis machines more expensive than 5-axis machines?
Yes, 7-axis machines generally have a higher initial cost due to their advanced capabilities and the additional technology required. However, the potential for increased efficiency and precision may justify the investment for certain applications.

How can I determine which CNC machine is right for my business?
Assess your machining needs based on the complexity of parts, production volume, material types, and your long-term business goals. Consulting with a CNC machine expert can also help tailor the choice to your specific needs.

//]]>